Biology 334 - Flowering Plants   Dr. Janet L. Gehring

EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR INDEPENDENT RESEARCH PROJECT AND PAPER
 

Abstract
5%
  • Summary of the entire article giving the main features and results of the study
  • Usually only one paragraph
  • Usually no literature citations
   
 Introduction
Write in the past tense
20%
  •  Cited literature provides background information on the topic and explains why the research is important and/or interesting.
  • Background information should be combined with a persuasive line of reasoning (i.e., logic) to develop the hypothesis.
  • The hypothesis (or goals or predictions) of the study MUST be explicitly stated.
   
 Methods and Materials
Write in the past tense
20%
  • Experimental design MUST be appropriate for testing the hypothesis
  • Adequate sample size (based on review of literature)
  • Description of species (only pertinent details need to be included)
  • Concise description of techniques (published techniques can be cited without being described in detail).
  • Diagrams of study area or experimental design can be helpful (but are not necessary).
   
Results
Write in the past tense
20%
  • The Results section includes 1) a compilation of the data (in tables and figures), 2) the outcome of statistical procedures, and 3) a prose summary in which the most important findings are highlighted.
  • Data should be clearly presented (in tables, figures, and prose) so that interesting/important patterns are obvious.
  • No interpretation or conclusions in the results.
  • Figures and tables should be cited in the prose summary like this (Fig. 1,) or like this (Table 1, Fig. 1). Figures and tables should be numbered in the order in which they are cited (i.e., the first figure to be discussed is Fig. 1).
  • Figure legends and table captions MUST be present. They should be descriptive but as short as possible. Figure legends are placed below the figures. Table captions are placed above the tables.
   
Discussion
Write in present tense
20%
  • Evaluate the results in terms of the original hypothesis.
  • The results should be compared with previous work on the topic (citing pertinent literature).
  • If the results are unexpected or contradictory to previous work (citing pertinent literature), possible explanations should be proposed.
   
Presentation
10%
  • Ideas should be grouped into paragraphs that are introduced by topic sentences.
  • In the Introduction and Discussion, there must be a clear flow of ideas from paragraph to paragraph.
  • BE CONCISE! Redundancy and the inclusion of extraneous material detract from the quality and readability of the paper. GET and KEEP to the point!
  • Word choice and punctuation should be correct and appropriate. Sentence structure is expected to be grammatically correct. Sentences should vary in length and construction.
  • Do not start sentences with "I believe" or "I think." Obviously if you’ve written it, you thought it.
  • NO results in Discussion, NO methods in Results, NO methods in Introduction.
   
Literature Cited
5%
  • In the body of the paper, literature can be cited in two ways, either as a parenthetical statement (see Ex. 1) or as part of the sentence (see Ex. 2).
  • Ex. 1: Significant differences in allele frequencies among populations were not correlated with soil moisture gradients (Gehring and Linhart, 1992).
  • Ex. 2: Gehring and Linhart (1992) found significant differences in allele and genotype frequencies among populations, but those differences were not correlated with soil moisture gradients.
  • In citations in the body of the paper, you may use "et al." for papers with more than two authors (Doe et al., 1999).
  • All published work cited in the paper must be listed in Literature Cited. 
  • In the Literature Cited section, alphabetize references according to the last name of the first author, then the last name of the 2nd author, etc., then by year. ALL authors must be included in the reference (i.e., don’t use et al. in the Literature Cited section).

 

This page last modified on August 23, 2000. 880 visits since 08/23/00.