Solution to Problem 219


A correct solution came from Bradley University students Dan Keshen, Ryan Collins.  Another correct solution was submitted by Lou Cairoli. 


There are 16 such simple fractions.  

This is one of those situations in mathematics where it is easier to solve the more general problem:   There are 2n-2 simple fractions that can be built from the n primes a1, ... , an.  Let's show this by induction, using the trivial case n = 2 to anchor the induction. 

First note that whenever you simplify a complex fraction like the ones in the statement of the problem a1 will end up in the numerator and a2 in the denominator; this is easy to see but the skeptics can verify it by induction.  Since a1 ends up in the numerator and a2 ends up in the denominator, and each of the other n - 2 primes can end up in (at most) one of these, it follows that you can realize at most 2n-2 simple fractions as complex fractions.  Let's show that, in fact, any simple fraction with a1 in the numerator and a2 in the denominator can be so realized.  

Let N  and be the numerator and denominator of the desired simple fraction.  Let N = a1 ai+1 N ' and D = a2 ... ai D ' so that i is the smallest index with i > 1 for which ai+1 appears in the numerator.  By induction, you can realize the simple fraction F1 = a1 /(a2 ... ai-1); similarly, you can realize the simple fraction F2 = (ai D ') /(ai+1 N ').  Therefore, the complex fraction F1 / F2 realizes N /D.

You are visitor number 2078 to this page.
©2005 Alberto L. Delgado